0 Comments

Our second test involved testing capacity and stability by filling each rack with dishes. For our test, we used four large dinner plates, four drinking glasses, four sets of flatware, a 5-quart Dutch oven, and a 10-inch frying pan. Separately, we tested each rack out to see how well they handled bowls, specifically whether the design made it possible to rack them up standing up or if you had to place them down flat, which takes up much more space.


What makes a good drying rack?

We were most interested in a dish rack’s ability to function under a wide variety of space constraints. We liked the idea of a dish rack that could accommodate different spatial needs and could adapt itself to the given moment. Stationary dish racks can take up a lot of counter space, so a collapsible dish rack or one that could otherwise stow away or be easily moved was a strong contender in our eyes.

Even if you do a good job of hand-drying, a dish rack is still a pretty wet environment, and it can get funky and gross, which is why having one that is easy to clean and disassemble is a huge must. You should expect that a dish rack is something you clean on a fairly regular basis, so the easier it is to do that, the better. We also gave positive marks to anything with rustproof or rust-resistant features.

We were less concerned with how much stuff could fit in the dish rack than we were with how many ways things could fit in a dish rack. A design that lends itself to a variety of orientations and can support all kinds of dishes in the same space is better than a dish rack that has a bunch of separate, specifically designated sections for things at the cost of taking up more room.


Other dish racks we tested

This is a favorite dish rack among many review sites, and we liked it too. Just not as much as the Joseph Joseph. It has a sturdy stainless-steel build and a smart design with a simple slide-out drip tray, making it very easy to clean. Our only gripe with it is that you can’t control the direction of the drip tray angles. This means that it has to sit on your countertop at its widest orientation, making this an impractical choice for people short on counter space. When choosing a winner, we wanted to pick something that would provide greater adaptability (people move, kitchen setups change). However, if you have the space to accommodate this rack, it’s a great choice.

Simple Human Dish Drying Rack

Simple Human Dish Drying Rack

Simplehuman Dish Drying Rack

As to be expected with a Simple Human product, this dish rack is thoughtfully designed with unique features. It has a rack for hanging stemware and a hydrophilic coating on the basin that spreads water out for faster evaporation. This is the largest dish rack we tested, so if this is what you want, be sure you have plenty of room for it. We would have liked more pegs for supporting dishes upright. Also the drain was a bit difficult to clean compared to other dish racks. If you find yourself hand-washing a lot of wine glasses, this might be your model of choice, though. Overall, this is a high-quality stainless-steel dish rack that is worth it if you have the space.

Kitsure Dish Rack

This was one of the more affordable dish racks we found. It can function on the countertop, suspend over the kitchen sink, or sit inside it. It has a plastic drainage base and a wire metal construction that’s easy to clean, and it could hold all the dishes required in our test. The materials felt a little cheap, though, making us wonder about its longevity. Longer testing is needed for us to potentially rate it higher, but overall, this is a good, versatile choice.

Umbra Sink Dish Drying Rack

Umbra Sink Dish Drying Rack

Umbra Sink Dish Drying Rack

Like the Kitsure, this is a versatile caddy designed to either go in the sink, suspend over it, or, theoretically, sit next to it (although it doesn’t have any base for that). It is pretty affordable and has a modest but workable capacity. Some buyers have complained about the feet rusting, which is worth noting. It would also be great if it came with an optional drain board like the Kitsure. But, alas…


Dish racks we don’t recommend

We appreciated the attempt at making a dish rack that folds up when not in use, but the plastic components were bulky and rigid and had to be forced open. We also found this one tricky to clean due to an abundance of nooks and crannies.

We weren’t crazy about the plastic ridges on this dish rack, which we felt were unnecessarily bulky. The design also felt cramped compared to other models we tested.

The problems with this dish rack are that it lacked sides, which are helpful for providing additional support when piling dishes high, and that the drip tray was not very effective at containing moisture. To use this dish rack, we’d recommend placing a towel underneath it to avoid any messes. It was, at least, one of the easiest dish racks to clean.

We appreciate this as a playful and clever kitchen gadget, but ultimately this dish rack is best used for bottles and small kitchen accessories. It isn’t particularly helpful for dishes and larger pots.

This is another diatomaceous earth drying rack that’s on the smaller side. The pegs and ridges couldn’t really accommodate larger dishes, and it lacked any space for drying utensils, cutting boards, or silverware.


More shopping stories on Bon Appétit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts